Best Bets’ On an Unhistoric Night was my favorite record of 2022, and their follow-up, The Hollow Husk of Feeling, might just take the top spot this year as well. This new album has all the elements that first made me fall in love with the New Zealanders: punchy rhythms, jangly guitars, a touch of angst, and irresistible melodies. Their powerpop is a brilliant blend of Britpop, power pop, New Zealand underground pop, and American indierock (listen to the very Superchunk-like When You Walk Out), created by musicians who clearly own more than a few classic punk records. Best Bets plays with the fervor of a fresh-faced band but delivers their songs with the confidence of seasoned veterans.
The record kicks off with Heaven, an anthem perfect for rolling down the windows and belting out the chorus. Then comes Sylvania Waters, an upbeat, sunny jangle-pop hit that keeps the momentum going. Monster follows as one of those quintessential Best Bets songs, with a verse brimming with nervous energy and a chorus that sticks like glue. By the time we’re three songs in, I’m already messaging my brother Dennis (aka Add to Wantlist’s head honcho) to say this album is shaping up to be a repeat favorite.
And the hits just keep coming. Hairshirt is fueled by infectious organ riffs, Spooky Signals is an earworm you won’t shake, and Autumn Morning is a pure powerpop gem. The Last Grand Prix adds a playful twist, while Pensacola showcases a tight bass and guitar love affair. Then there’s the heartfelt power ballad When You Walk Out, the short and speedy Malaise Era, the rockin’ Pillory Parade, and finally, We Are Prepared, which might just be the most New Zealand-sounding track of the bunch.
Yes, I’ve basically listed every song on the album — and yes, it’s that good. The Hollow Husk of Feeling is out now on Meritorio and Melted Ice Cream, and it’s another scorcher from Best Bets. Don’t sleep on it.